DISCLAIMER: The card shop information presented below does not represent an endorsement. The info has been gathered from websites, social media profiles, and other public-facing websites. The blurbs are summaries of reviews from Google, Facebook, etc. I always encourage you to do your own research before making any visits.
Evansville has established itself as a vibrant hub for baseball card and sports memorabilia enthusiasts, drawing passionate collectors from across the region. While the city’s rich minor league baseball heritage—including the historic Evansville Otters—creates a strong local baseball culture, the area’s dedicated shops cater to collectors of all major sports and eras. From vintage wax packs and graded rookies to signed memorabilia and game-worn jerseys, Evansville’s specialty retailers stock inventory that rivals much larger markets, regularly hosting breaks, authentication events, and collector meetups. Whether you’re hunting for that elusive card to complete your set or seeking authenticated collectibles, explore our curated directory of local shops below to discover your next favorite destination.
Own a shop on this page? I can update hours, photos, and listing details in just a few minutes. Contact me. Want to boost your shop’s visibility? Check out our ad options.
The Hobby Den
The Hobby Den
5432 E Indiana St, Evansville, IN 47715, USA
+1 812-805-0058
This beloved local shop specializes in sports cards and memorabilia with an impressive selection of Pokémon cards and excellent inventory variety. The knowledgeable and friendly staff, including standouts like David and Meg, go above and beyond—offering honest pricing, grading guidance, and personalized service without pressure. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or nostalgic beginner, you’ll find fair trade rates, genuine enthusiasm for the hobby, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps collectors coming back.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Upscale Trading Cards
Upscale Trading Cards
3830 N First Ave, Evansville, IN 47710, USA
+1 812-303-2701
Located in Evansville, this sports card and memorabilia destination delivers an exceptional experience for collectors of all levels. The welcoming staff genuinely care about helping you find exactly what you need, whether you’re a seasoned enthusiast or just starting out. With an impressive inventory of cards and memorabilia paired with fair pricing, you’ll spend hours discovering gems—and the friendly atmosphere makes every visit feel like catching up with old friends who share your passion for the hobby.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING
CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING
900 Tutor Ln #104, Evansville, IN 47715, USA
+1 812-777-5163
Located in Evansville, this clean and well-organized card shop stands out for its knowledgeable, welcoming staff who excel at offering expert guidance on grading, pricing, and collection building. Whether you’re looking to buy sealed products, sell your collection, or get advice on TCGs and sports memorabilia, the team takes genuine time with every customer and delivers fair offers without the typical haggling. A refreshingly professional atmosphere makes this a favorite destination for serious collectors and casual hobbyists alike.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Main Phase One
Main Phase One
500 N Congress Ave Suite D, Evansville, IN 47715, USA
+1 812-215-2174
Located in downtown Evansville, this collector-focused card shop offers competitive pricing on TCG products like Pokémon and Lorcana without the price gouging found elsewhere. The knowledgeable staff—particularly Ryan, Spencer, and Easton—are genuinely invested in supporting the local gaming community with thoughtful service and a welcoming atmosphere. With a large inventory spanning multiple card games, regular events, and complimentary snacks and drinks, this is a destination shop for serious collectors and casual players alike.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
The Card Shop Machine
The Card Shop Machine
800 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715, USA
+1 270-969-0126
Located in Evansville, this sports card and memorabilia destination offers a solid selection for local collectors seeking convenience and hands-on browsing. While the inventory focuses on traditional sports cards rather than Pokémon, the shop provides an accessible spot to hunt for additions to your collection. Keep in mind that pricing runs higher than online marketplaces like TCGplayer and eBay, so experienced collectors may want to compare values before purchasing.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
The Book Broker
The Book Broker
2717 Covert Ave, Evansville, IN 47714, USA
+1 812-479-5647
Located in Evansville, this collectibles destination specializes in trading cards, comics, DVDs, and music with an emphasis on competitive gaming. The shop hosts regular tournaments for Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokémon players and maintains a substantial back-stock of comics upstairs. While the inventory and selection appeal to serious collectors, customer experiences vary significantly depending on staff interactions—some visits showcase friendly, professional service, while others report frustratingly inconsistent treatment. Best suited for dedicated card and comic enthusiasts willing to work with the shop’s browsing policies.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Evansville Toys & Games
Evansville Toys & Games
3810 E Morgan Ave, Evansville, IN 47715, USA
+1 812-909-0029
This beloved local destination offers an impressive variety of sports cards, memorabilia, toys, games, and comic books that appeal to collectors and casual enthusiasts alike. The main shop features passionate, knowledgeable staff who genuinely love helping customers navigate their collections. While inventory is extensive and selection impressive, collector feedback suggests comparing prices with market value before purchasing sealed products, and visiting when core staff members are present ensures the best experience.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Evansville Otters Team Store
Evansville Otters Team Store
23 Don Mattingly Way, Evansville, IN 47711, USA
+1 812-435-8686
Shop Located right at the ballpark, this dedicated sports card and memorabilia destination is a must-visit for collectors seeking quality inventory and authentic pieces. The shop specializes in baseball cards, vintage memorabilia, and local Otters merchandise, making it the perfect spot to enhance your collection or grab game-day souvenirs. Whether you’re a seasoned hobbyist hunting for rare finds or a casual fan looking to support local, the knowledgeable staff brings genuine passion for the hobby and helps visitors discover their next great addition.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
The Loot Box
The Loot Box
1118 IN-662 Unit A, Newburgh, IN 47630, USA
+1 812-518-3059
This charming hometown card and collectibles shop offers a carefully curated selection of trading card games like Pokémon and Magic, vintage board games, puzzles, and hobby supplies that punches well above its modest size. The knowledgeable and genuinely friendly staff takes pride in helping collectors find exactly what they’re seeking, with fair pricing and regular restocks that keep enthusiasts coming back. It’s an inviting, family-friendly destination perfect for both serious hobbyists and casual browsers exploring the local collecting scene.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Comic Quest
Comic Quest
8401 N Kentucky Ave, Evansville, IN 47725, USA
+1 812-474-1133
This expansive collectibles destination stocks an impressive array of comics, trading cards, action figures, board games, and manga in a well-organized space that makes browsing enjoyable whether you’re hunting for specific releases or diving into back issues. The knowledgeable staff creates a welcoming atmosphere, and the shop regularly hosts gaming sessions and community events like One Piece nights that draw dedicated collectors. Whether you’re a longtime hobbyist or new to the scene, you’ll find friendly service and the variety serious collectors crave.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.