DISCLAIMER: The card shop information presented below does not represent an endorsement. The info has been gathered from websites, social media profiles, and other public-facing websites. The blurbs are summaries of reviews from Google, Facebook, etc. I always encourage you to do your own research before making any visits.
Madison’s vibrant sports culture and passionate fan base make it an ideal destination for baseball card and sports memorabilia enthusiasts. While the city doesn’t host a major professional team, the strong local connection to Wisconsin sports—particularly the Green Bay Packers and Milwaukee Brewers—creates a robust collector community eager for vintage cards, modern releases, and rare memorabilia. Local shops in Madison regularly stock everything from classic tobacco cards to contemporary rookie editions, and many host trading events, breaks, and authentication services that keep collectors engaged year-round. Explore the shops listed below to discover your next prized addition and connect with fellow fans who share your passion for the hobby.
Own a shop on this page? I can update hours, photos, and listing details in just a few minutes. Contact me. Want to boost your shop’s visibility? Check out our ad options.
Rabbit Hole Sports Cards
Rabbit Hole Sports Cards
150 E Towne Way, Madison, WI 53704, USA
+1 608-285-9614
Welcome to Madison’s premier destination for sports cards and memorabilia. This collector-friendly shop offers an impressive selection of autographed jerseys, graded cards, singles, and vintage memorabilia, all professionally displayed and competitively priced. The knowledgeable owner is genuinely passionate about helping collectors find their next treasure, whether you’re hunting for specific cards or looking to sell from your collection—you’ll receive fair offers and expert guidance every visit.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
BMW Sportscards
BMW Sportscards
555 D’onofrio Dr Suite 103, Madison, WI 53719, USA
+1 608-833-5515
Brian’s shop is a must-visit destination for sports card and memorabilia enthusiasts seeking expert evaluation and fair pricing. The knowledgeable owner personally assesses your collection while you wait, making the experience engaging and transparent—whether you’re selling vintage cards, coins, or other sports treasures. With three decades of trusted relationships in the hobby, Brian combines deep expertise with genuine friendliness, creating a welcoming environment where collectors of all ages feel valued and understood.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Slab Factory – Sports & Trading Cards
Slab Factory – Sports & Trading Cards
739 N High Point Rd, Madison, WI 53717, USA
+1 608-620-8304
Located in Madison, this sports card shop delivers an exceptional collecting experience with a constantly rotating inventory of cards and memorabilia across all major sports. The knowledgeable and enthusiastic staff genuinely care about helping collectors—whether you’re seeking specific chase cards, needing grading services, or just looking for honest advice on card values. The relaxed, welcoming atmosphere and reasonable pricing make it a go-to destination for both seasoned hobbyists and newcomers to the hobby.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Jim’s Card Korner LLC
Jim’s Card Korner LLC
2865 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705, USA
+1 608-233-0045
Located on Madison’s University Avenue, this long-established shop specializes in sports cards and memorabilia with a particular focus on local and regional teams and players. The owner brings nearly three decades of expertise to the hobby, offering genuine knowledge of card valuations and a curated inventory that emphasizes raw cards over slabbed versions. Beyond the display cases, extensive dollar boxes reward patient collectors willing to dig for hidden gems in this treasure trove of vintage and modern cardboard.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Steve Schmitt’s Sports Treasures Plus
Steve Schmitt’s Sports Treasures Plus
1016 Nygaard St, Stoughton, WI 53589, USA
+1 608-354-3389
Steve Schmitt’s passion for sports shines throughout this treasure trove of collectibles, featuring extensive inventory spanning trading cards, memorabilia, bobbleheads, and athlete wall décor across professional and local high school sports. Beyond the impressive displays, the shop offers interactive entertainment including vintage arcade games, cornhole, and claw machines, creating an experience that feels like exploring a personal museum. The owner’s friendly, knowledgeable presence and genuine enthusiasm for sports make this a must-visit destination for serious collectors and casual fans alike.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Price’s Collectibles
Price’s Collectibles
5626 Broad St, Greendale, WI 53129, USA
+1 414-377-9092
Located in Greendale, this beloved collectibles destination offers an impressive selection spanning sports cards, Pokémon, Star Wars, and memorabilia, with knowledgeable staff ready to share grading advice and collector stories. Owner Jeff creates a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere where both serious collectors and casual enthusiasts feel at home, and the shop also handles PSA and SGC submissions. With fair pricing, hard-to-find inventory, and a reputation built on honesty and personable service, it’s a must-visit for anyone passionate about building their collection.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Bonsai Cards & Collectibles
Bonsai Cards & Collectibles
613 S Main St, DeForest, WI 53532, USA
+1 608-842-0160
Located in DeForest, Wisconsin, this premier sports card and memorabilia shop offers an exceptional selection of singles and wax across baseball, football, and Pokémon. The knowledgeable and welcoming staff consistently hit big with inventory quality and fair market pricing, plus competitive buy offers at 70-75% of comp value. Whether you’re a serious collector or casual hobbyist, this is the place to inspect cards in person, avoid shipping costs, and support a thriving local business that genuinely cares about the hobby community.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Mr. Wilson’s Card Shop
Mr. Wilson’s Card Shop
207 Lodi St, Lodi, WI 53555, USA
+1 608-592-4890
Located in Lodi, Wisconsin, this beloved sports card and memorabilia destination offers an impressive selection of sealed wax, competitive single cards, and hard-to-find supplies like top loaders. The owner’s genuine passion for sports and collecting creates a welcoming atmosphere that appeals equally to seasoned collectors and newcomers exploring the hobby. With fair pricing, extensive inventory, and knowledgeable staff who love talking sports, this shop has earned a loyal following among the local collecting community.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Dude’s Card Shop
Dude’s Card Shop
130 N Main St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538, USA
+1 920-397-7151
This Fort Atkinson sports card shop boasts an impressive inventory of vintage and modern singles, slabbed and raw cards, along with collectible memorabilia and autographed items. The knowledgeable staff provides excellent customer service and fair pricing, making it a standout destination for serious collectors throughout Southeast Wisconsin. Whether you’re hunting for Hall of Famers, local Brewers cards, or rare vintage finds, this shop delivers a quality buying experience that rivals larger regional card shows.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.
Jeff’s Sports, Inc.
Jeff’s Sports, Inc.
14165 W Capitol Dr, Brookfield, WI 53005, USA
+1 262-781-2546
Located in Brookfield, this beloved sports card and memorabilia destination offers an impressive selection of collectibles spanning vintage to contemporary releases. The knowledgeable staff brings genuine passion and enthusiasm to help collectors of all experience levels—from curious kids just starting out to seasoned enthusiasts. Beyond retail, the shop provides expert framing services and creates a welcoming community atmosphere where you can confidently find quality cards, memorabilia, and personalized guidance for your collection.
👉 Own this shop? Fix or update your info
Want more visibility for your shop?
Get featured with photos, links, and event visibility. Featured shops appear at the top of the page and get the most visibility.