Ryan Barone (@ballcardgenius, Card Expert) is a lifelong member of the hobby. He has been quoted in PSA Magazine, and his content has regularly been mentioned in “Quick Rips” (the Topps RIPPED Newsletter) and across other hobby publications. hello@ballcardgenius.com; Last Time Ago LLC dba Ballcard Genius.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As I am a part of the eBay Partner Network and other programs, if you follow these links and make a purchase, I’ll receive commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Donruss and Optic are similar products, with Donruss being the the lower end “paper” version on traditional card stock, and Optic being the higher end, “chromium” counterpart. Just like Topps Flagship and Topps Chrome cards use the same player photos but with a slightly different checklist, Donruss has a larger checklist with more players while Optic features a smaller more premium checklist.
To get a feel for the true difference between the two sets, here is a look at how they compare for 2022 Donruss and 2022 Optic Football.
| 2022 Football Feature | Donruss | Optic |
| Base Set | 300 Cards | 200 Cards |
| Rated Rookies | 100 Cards | 100 Cards |
| Current Hobby Box Price | ~$285 | ~$800 |
| Hobby Box Configuration | 10 cards per pack 18 packs per box | 4 cards per pack 20 packs per box |
| Hobby Box Hits | 1 Autograph and 1 Relic 18 Rated Rookie Cards 12 Parallels 42 Inserts | 1 Autograph 8 #’d Parallels and 2 Additional Parallels 4 Inserts 20 Rated Rookie Cards |
| SSPs | Gridiron Marvels Night Moves Rated Rookie Premium. | NA |
| Chance at a Downtown | Yes | Yes |
As you can see, the Donruss Optic checklist has a smaller base set but features more parallels and inserts. It also has a wider variety of autographs, including some limited-edition options. The Donruss checklist is more focused on rookies, with 100 Rated Rookie cards compared to Optic’s 100. Ultimately, the best checklist for you will depend on your collecting preferences.
Card Design and Quality
Donruss cards typically have a more classic or traditional design and paper stock feel. Thus, the focus is more on the player images and less on flashy designs or holographic elements that a chrome card can better provide.
Read More: Donruss Press Proofs
As such, Optic cards are known for their chrome finish and higher-end look. They often include refractor-like cards “Prizms” or “Silvers” or “Holos” (in Panini and collector terminology) and have a more modern and in-your-face appearance and feel.
Variety and Inserts
Let’s just cut to the chase—both Donruss and Optic include the coveted Downtown (and Super Bowl Downtown) inserts, which is enough of a draw in itself. Beyond that, though, Donruss (not Optic) offers a number of cool SSPs (super short prints).
Popularity and Price:
Donruss is more affordable and accessible for casual or perhaps young collectors, while still providing plenty of chase cards. Optic then, tends to be more expensive and are often sought after by serious collectors. The premium nature of the cards, along with the popularity of certain inserts and parallels, can drive up prices, and attracts collectors who enjoy modern designs, shiny cards, and are possibly looking for investment-grade items.
