Ultimate Guide to Baseball Card Appraisals—Put a Price on Your Collection

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog post contains affiliate links to eBay, Target, Walmart, and other platforms. As I am part of the eBay Partner Network and other affiliate programs, if you follow these links and make a purchase, I will receive a small commission (at no cost to you). I do this in order to keep the blog afloat, but also to showcase the products I’m talking about, and to facilitate your collecting of them. Happy hunting!

Disclosure: This content is for informational purposes only. I am not suggesting one service or method over another, nor am I offering to appraise your collection.

What is a baseball card appraisal?

A baseball card appraisal is the process of an unbiased third party reviewing your collection and placing a value on it based on its makeup.

When getting your cards appraised, it’s in your best interest to receive appraisals from multiple sources. And, as mentioned, you’ll want to have the party doing the appraisal to not have any “skin in the game,” as Warren Buffet would say.

If you don’t have time to read the entire page, and are just looking for baseball card appraisals, here is a running list (Let me know if you suggest any to be added to the list:

Why get your baseball cards appraised?

First, there are many people out there wondering if baseball cards are even worth anything and if card collecting is still a viable hobby. It’s a semi-valid assertion, given the ups and downs of what used to be considered the hobby of all hobbies.

If you’ve also had the same questions, and have a collection yourself, let the card appraisal be the answer. for others, you would typically get your collection appraised proceeding a related event. Meaning, if you were planning on selling your collection, it would be in your best interest to get it valued.

In addition, perhaps you’re needing your collection to be insured, as a part of your home owner’s or renter’s policy, or because you’re mailing it, in which case you’d need it appraised also. Or, you’re planning on gifting your collection to someone else and would like to let them know the approximate value.

Last, you might have received a few baseball cards for free and was gifted the collection from someone else, or through the purchase of a storage locker, etc. and are just curious as to the price of your treasure (but again, probably because you are wanting to turn around and sell it).

Rarely will you be motivated to get your collection appraised unless you’re planning on taking some sort of action with it.

What are the pros and cons involved with appraisal?

Pros: The overall benefit of getting your collection appraised is to attach some sort of tangible value to it. In addition to the cases above, this comes in handy if you want some sort of baseline value for a collection you know you will be building. Attaching value is also a reason why you should get your cards graded.

Cons: The cons are mostly related around the legitimacy of the actual appraisal value. Cards can quickly increase or decrease in value within a week’s time, especially with collections mostly made up of modern sets. On the other hand, vintage cards will remain more stable, if you will.

Another con is that your appraisal is, well, a con. Meaning, be cautious of anyone wanting to appraise your collection and then asking to immediately buy it after doing so. As you can imagine, any unsuspecting individual with a lack of card value knowledge can easily be taken advantage of during this process.

How to prepare your collection for appraisal

Before you get your cards appraised, you’ll need to do some preparation, which will vary depending on the route you choose (more on that below).

This includes, but not limited to taking photos of the cards you wish to sell and/or taking inventory and putting together a list of the cards you wish to sell, with their conditions.

Where can you get your cards appraised?

When it comes to get your cards appraised, you have a few options to consider:

Online with photos

There are online baseball card appraisal services through sites like Just Collect. In this case, getting your appraisal started is as easy as filling out the form and clicking a button.

Now, another online option is to utilize Beckett Certified Appraisal services, but some things to keep in mind.

First, the service is really only geared towards single print run cards, 1/1s essentially. Secondly, it’s $12/per card, and at that cost, I would just take my chances looking for similar 1/1 cards on eBay, or even putting up an auction with a “Best Offer” on the “Buy It Now” to gauge interest. eBay serves as a great option free price guide for baseball cards.

Online with a checklist

If you don’t have photos of your cards or don’t want to spend time putting them through the scanner, etc., you can usually have the appraiser look at a list of cards. Note, you can also do that with Just Collect, as mentioned above.

With this option, thought, you’ll want to make sure to include as much information as possible, especially around their condition, and be sure to list whether or not a card is a rare variation or a common, etc.

In-person, at a card shop

Many baseball card shops offer collection appraisals. With this option, you’re putting your cards into the hands of what should be a knowledgeable, trustworthy individual. The odds of them turning around and closing down their business just to run off with your collection should be low, and, they should have a very good idea on what cards are selling for. The problem is, there are less and less card shops every day.

One other thing to note is, the cards sold in shops are typically more expensive then those found online, given the overhead costs of running a physical brick and mortar cards store. So, don’t be put off if you receive a value for your cards, and then see the same cards in the shop’s case being sold for more money.

In-person, at a card show

If you can find a card show to attend, you might be able to find a “pop-up” appraiser who can look at your cards while you wait. Of course, this wouldn’t be the most thorough of options, but can work in some circumstances.

In-person, by appointment

In some cases, if the stars align, you can arrange for appraisers to meet you at your home. Given your intent of the appraisal, meaning, if you’d like to sell, the chances of finding a part to do an in-home appraisal increases greatly.

But, a word to the wise—you’re painting yourself into a bit of a corner with this option. Meaning, if you arrange for an appraiser to travel to you, they know you’re ready to sell, and, with them in your living room, they can go about quoting a lower price in hopes that you’ll accept, given the sheer convenience.

If you’re looking to get your graded cards appraised, PSA has a list of authorized dealers for you to refer to.

Via Snail Mail

Last, you might be able to ship your cards, the entire collection, to the appraiser. Now, I wouldn’t have the stomach to do so because you never know what could happen, but that is what is insurance is for, I guess (although, a bit of a catch 22 because you won’t know the true value of the collection with appraisal)!

You’ll also want to make sure you’ve adequately cataloged your cards before shipping them away, and then of course checking them upon return.

So, what’s the worth?

Have experience with any of these options or something different entirely? I’d love to talk about it in the comments!